Consider Jose. Kidnapped by cartel, ransom unpaid. Captors offer the usual career advice: join or die. He joins. They then require him to murder two other unpaid hostages. Refuse and die; comply and live. He complies, later escapes, and reports everything.
Should he be convicted of murder?
The orthodox reply is that one may not deliberately take an innocent life to preserve one's own. This sounds noble. It is also remarkably easy to pronounce from a safe distance. One wonders how many of its advocates would recite it with equal conviction while staring down the barrel.
Duress exists precisely because the law occasionally notices that people under imminent threat of death do not behave as free agents. Jose was not a volunteer. He was under physical control, faced credible execution, and went to the police the moment he could. To treat this as ordinary murder requires equating intentional action with voluntary action—an elementary confusion.
If he refuses, he dies. The intended victims may still die at the hands of the next coerced recruit. The organization continues. If he complies, survives, and assists the authorities, at least one of those outcomes is avoided. The victims remain dead either way; the moral arithmetic does not improve by adding Jose's corpse.
A legal system may, of course, declare certain boundaries absolute and demand self-sacrifice. That is a coherent (if austere) philosophical choice. What is not coherent is the pretence that the resulting conviction demonstrates moral equivalence between the professional killer and the man who killed because someone held a gun to his head.
If the law insists that a kidnapped man must die rather than kill under threat of execution, let it say so plainly: it requires martyrdom. Saints may find the vocation attractive. Ordinary defendants are under no obligation to share the enthusiasm.
This is the exact strategic trap Sun Tzu warned about in The Art of War when he advised generals to always leave a surrounded enemy an "escape route" (a golden bridge). If you corner an enemy with no chance of survival, they will fight with suicidal ferocity; if you give them a way out, they will surrender.